A company that grants options in March, sees a founder gift shares to a family trust in April and closes a funding round in June has been valued three times in one quarter. Tax compliance valuation is the work of making those three numbers tell the same story. If they do not, the IRS will notice before you do.
Three valuations, three different questions
Most founders I meet treat valuation as one number that sits somewhere in the data room. It does not work that way. A private company gets valued for a different reason each time, and each reason has a different reader on the other side of the table.
The 409A appraisal asks what a share of common stock is worth today, so that no option is priced below it. The gift or estate tax appraisal asks what a specific block of shares is worth when it is given away or passes at death. The priced funding round is not an appraisal at all, but it is the number every other document will be measured against.
Same company, same cap table, three documents. The trouble starts when each one is commissioned by a different person, at a different time, on different assumptions, and nobody puts them side by side. The IRS can. So can an auditor, or a lead manager at the listing stage. I would rather you did it first.
409A: the safe harbor is a process, not a stamp
Section 409A of the Internal Revenue Code treats an option priced below fair market value on the grant date as deferred compensation, and that comes with strict timing rules. Break them and the employee pays ordinary income tax on the spread when the option vests, a 20% additional tax on top, and interest. The employee carries the cost of a mistake the board made. That is why I treat 409A as a governance subject and not as a finance chore.
What the safe harbor gives you
The Treasury regulations (Treas. Reg. §1.409A-1(b)(5)(iv)) offer three routes to a presumption that your valuation is reasonable. For most venture-backed and pre-listing companies, only one is used in practice: an appraisal by a qualified independent appraiser. Once that is in place, the IRS can overturn the valuation only by showing that the method, or the way it was applied, was grossly unreasonable.
Two conditions keep the presumption alive. The valuation date must be within 12 months of the grant, and nothing material may have happened in between. A funding round, a sharp swing in revenue, an acquisition approach: any of these can end your reliance on the old number even if it is only four months old. There is no 90-day rule for the refresh. It is a judgement call, and the board should write down its reasoning either way.
One point for companies heading to a listing. The illiquid start-up presumption, which lets a young company rely on its own written valuation, is generally not available once an IPO is reasonably anticipated within 180 days. By then you need an independent appraisal.
A worked example
Take an illustrative company with an $80 million post-money equity value and 10 million fully diluted shares. The last preferred round priced at $8.00 a share. That is the headline, and it is not the strike price.
The appraiser allocates value between preferred and common, recognising liquidation preferences and other rights, and concludes that common stock is worth $5.60 a share on a marketable basis. A 20% discount for lack of marketability (DLOM) follows.
Common FMV per share = Marketable value × (1 − DLOM) = $5.60 × (1 − 0.20) = $4.48
The board grants 100,000 options at $4.48. Now compare the shortcut. Working from an old internal estimate, the board sets the strike at $3.00 and skips the appraisal. If the IRS later concludes that fair market value at grant was $4.48, the options were discounted by $1.48 a share, or $148,000 across the grant.
Say the stock is worth $9.00 when the options vest. The spread is $6.00 × 100,000 = $600,000, taxed as ordinary income in the year of vesting. The 20% additional tax adds another $120,000, before interest. The company also has withholding and reporting to deal with. The appraisal costs a fraction of that.
Estate and gift tax: the same fair market value, a harder audience
The numbers first, because they frame everything. For 2026 the federal lifetime estate and gift tax exemption is $15 million per person, or $30 million for a married couple. The annual gift exclusion stays at $19,000 per recipient, or $38,000 when spouses split a gift. A gift above the annual exclusion needs a gift tax return, due by April 15 of the following year, and it uses up part of the lifetime exemption (Morgan Lewis). Above the exemption, the top rate is 40%.
It is easy to assume that valuation matters less now that the exemption is this high. I would argue the opposite. A founder who gifts shares today spends exemption that cannot be recovered, and the value the IRS accepts for that gift decides how much is left.
What the IRS expects to see
The test is the familiar one: the price at which the interest would change hands between a willing buyer and a willing seller, both reasonably informed and neither under pressure. Revenue Ruling 59-60 sets out the factors an appraiser works through, from earnings and book value to the industry outlook and the prices of comparable listed companies. The valuation date is the date of the gift, or the date of death for an estate (or six months later, if the executor elects it and it lowers the estate).
Two details trip people up. Discounts for lack of marketability and for lack of control are legitimate, but they need data behind them, not rules of thumb. And a gift tax return that adequately discloses the transfer, which in practice means attaching a qualified appraisal, starts the clock on the IRS’s time to challenge the value. Without that, the clock may never start.
A worked example
Stay with the same company. A founder gifts 200,000 common shares, 2% of the company, to a family trust. The common stock value from the 409A analysis is the natural starting point, because it already reflects a non-controlling common interest and the rights that sit ahead of it.
Gift value = Shares × Common FMV per share = 200,000 × $4.48 = $896,000
That uses $896,000 of the $15 million exemption and leaves $14,104,000, assuming no earlier gifts. Now the trap. Someone reads the round price, takes 200,000 × $8.00 and reports $1,600,000. The gift is overstated by $704,000. If the donor’s exemption is already spent, that overstatement costs 40% × $704,000 = $281,600 in tax that was never owed.
The opposite error is just as costly. Report a figure the data cannot support and the IRS will adjust it, and penalties can follow.
IRS structural alignment: one story across three documents
Tax compliance valuation comes down to one question I put to every client who holds more than one of these documents: if the IRS laid them side by side, would they tell the same story?
Valuation | Question it answers | Who relies on it | How long it holds | Who bears the downside |
409A appraisal | Fair market value of common stock, for option strike prices | Board, employees, IRS | Up to 12 months, less after a material event | Employee (tax on the spread plus 20%) and the company’s withholding |
Gift or estate appraisal | Fair market value of the interest transferred | Donor or estate, IRS | Valuation date only: date of gift or of death | Donor or estate (gift or estate tax, penalties) |
Priced funding round | Price investors paid for preferred stock | Investors, founders | A single closing date | No direct tax cost, but every other valuation is measured against it |
The documents answer different questions, so the numbers will differ. That is fine. What is not fine is a difference nobody has explained. Suppose the 409A puts common at $4.48 in April and a gift appraisal in May puts the same shares at $8.00. One of the two is wrong. If $8.00 is right, the options were granted below fair market value. If $4.48 is right, the gift was overstated and the donor used exemption that was not needed. Either way, someone has to explain it, and a memo written now is easier than an explanation given during an examination.
The consistency test
Before any grant, gift or filing, I ask for five things on one page:
- The same cap table and share count behind every report.
- A written bridge from the last priced round to each report’s equity value.
- The same method for allocating value to common stock, or a stated reason for using a different one.
- Discounts tied to data, with the reasons for any difference between reports written down.
- A reconciliation of any two valuations dated within roughly 90 days of each other. That window is my own rule of thumb, not a regulatory one.
Where this lands for Indian groups with US exposure
This is a US tax subject, so why does it matter at Omnifin? Because many of the companies we advise have a US touchpoint: a US subsidiary granting options to American employees, founders who hold a US passport or green card, or promoters whose family structures hold US assets.
A US subsidiary granting options to its US staff needs a 409A valuation even if the parent is Indian. A founder who is a US person and plans to gift shares needs a gift appraisal that agrees with the numbers on the company’s own books. And a founder who is not a US person but holds shares in a US company can face US estate tax on that holding, at a threshold far below the $15 million above. That last one belongs with US counsel early.
The discipline carries over at home. Indian rules on share valuation, whether under the Income-tax Rules or the FEMA pricing guidelines, ask for the same things: a documented method and a defined valuation date. A company that already reconciles its US and Indian valuations is better prepared when a lead manager and a regulator start asking questions ahead of a listing.
Board checklist before any grant, gift or round
Before the next option grant, gift or funding round, I would want the board to be able to tick each of these.
- The appraiser is qualified and independent, and the board approved the engagement before work started.
- The valuation date is within 12 months of every grant date in the pipeline.
- Someone has listed the material events since the valuation date, and the board has recorded its decision on each.
- The equity value bridges to the last priced round, in writing.
- The 409A report, any gift appraisals and the estate planning files use the same cap table.
- Every discount has data behind it, and any difference between reports is explained.
- Gift appraisals are qualified and attached to the gift tax return with adequate disclosure.
- If a listing is in view, the company is not leaning on the illiquid start-up presumption.
- One person owns the valuation file, and the board minutes or written consents are in it.
Next step
If equity compensation, family wealth planning and an IPO are all on your calendar, line the valuations up before someone else does it for you. Write to us at valuation@omnifinsolutions.com and we will start with the one-page consistency test.
Disclaimer: This article is for general information on US federal tax valuation concepts and is not tax, legal or investment advice. The figures are for tax year 2026 and the worked examples are illustrative. Speak to qualified US tax counsel before acting on any of it.